Let me start by stating comparing the Buffalo Creek project with the Seneca Niagara Casino doesn’t work. The neighborhoods are not the same, neither are the local economic drivers. This article seems to be your standard “Woe is us, we have a casino” type deal. Pictures of run - down houses with the Casino complex in the background always tugs at my heart strings. You get great quotes like this:
“You could build a wall around the casino and the hotel for all the good they do for neighboring businesses,” said Buffalo developer Carl A. Paladino, who is trying to redevelop the second-tallest building in Niagara Falls, a block from the casino.
Carl is right. The local bars and restaurants are in direct competition with the casino. But then again why would visitors coming to the casino leave for food and drink when they don’t have to.
Does this come as a surprise?
Let’s look at this a minute…
Niagara Falls. sits on one of the greatest natural wonders of the world, and attracts thousands upon thousands of tourists each year. Yet the city I once called home is a dump, has been for years. The hotel business is doing alright. Matter of fact, there are a few million in upgrades going on right now. But these tourists don’t frequent local bars and eateries on Main, Pine, or around the casino. What made people think that another tourist attraction would be any different?
What does the casino bring to the area anyhow?
Almost 3,000 jobs, a 76 million payroll. And the city of Niagara Falls will receive 23 million this year. Not too bad.
What does the city bring to the table?
A dysfunctional government that makes Buffalo and Erie County look efficient as hell. A merry go round of mayors that provide endless fodder for Mike Hudson to write about, including a mayor under investigation by the FBI, and whose daughter purportedly held a drinking party in his office.
Has the city provided any incentives for businesses to move into that area? Has any program been initiated for current businesses to receive tax breaks for improvement? Is there anything in place where the city and casino jointly promote the local businesses in conjunction with the casino?
As for the run down homes in that area, they were like that pre-casino, so that’s a wash. And you can’t convince me that there are not some property owners in that area just maintaining the status quo, hoping that someone will buy the property at an inflated values just because of the proximity to the casino.
Bottom line - Seneca Niagara is a business. It is not their responsibility to pull that area up by its bootstraps. Business owners have to work that themselves. The city government has to pull its head out and offer incentives to make it worthwhile to invest.
If anything, that is the lesson that Buffalo has to learn. If the Casino does happen, do not sit back and wait for the magic to happen. The district must be marketed properly, and you have to work with the casino for things to happen.
Oh, for the record, I have never set foot in any casino anywhere. Not even for the food and entertainment. Not my cup of tea.